Tyler Carter is a healthy-eating gym owner who doesn't bake. When his employees enter him into a bake-off contest to raise money for Harry's House, an after school space for kids commemorating local first responder Harry Monroe, he needs to learn-fast! Shy special needs teacher Stacey Allman loves to bake and often dreams of sharing her confections with her uber fit, gorgeous neighbor. So when Tyler sets off his smoke alarm and explains his dilemma, she can't resist the temptation of playing pastry chef tutor. He offers boxing lessons in exchange. More time together? Yes please, But when Tyler's ex comes back to Marietta asking for his help, will it derail Stacey and Tyler's chance at love, or will it make them see that they're the perfect fit?