Naomi King has a perfect track record when it comes to matchmaking—not only has she successfully matched her two best friends with their husbands, she also introduced her sister Priscilla to her fiancé. Now with her sister's wedding right around the corner, Naomi wonders why she's able to find husbands for her friends and family, but not one for herself. At age twenty-nine, Zeke Lapp is a confirmed bachelor. The problem is, he doesn't want to be. But despite his family and friends' attempts at matching him up with the single women in his community of Middlefield, he still hasn't found the one for him. He wonders if he ever will. Zeke arrives in Paradise to help his cousin finish the house he's building for his soon-to-be new wife. A month before the wedding, he meets the bride's sister, Naomi, a pretty girl with a bubbly personality. From the moment they meet, Zeke is attracted to Naomi. But Naomi tries to set him up with her friend Margaret, who is desperate for a mate. Hiding her unexpected feelings for Zeke, she is reluctant but loyal to her friend. When the date is a disaster, Naomi comforts her friend but cannot deny her growing feelings. As Zeke and Naomi grow closer, so does their reliance on God's will for their future and in a moment of honesty, both reveal what's holding them back. Will they be able to overcome these obstacles and find true love?